Competitor teardown benchmarking is the process of studying our customer's product in comparison with their competitor's products to assess differences in features, architecture, BOM and should cost of all parts by tearing down the products to their last child parts.


Different aspects of benchmarking data captured by Advanced Structures India are meant for different usage inside your organization. Images shown on this page are either from our internal projects or are heavily edited to change numbers and specifics.

Advanced Structures India teardown of 3 wheeler for benchmarking banner

Feature Benchmarking

Before tearing down the vehicle, we map all its features on product level. During teardown, we map subsystem level features. This is later linked with corresponding BOM items used for providing the feature to get feature based cost benchmarkin.

feature benchmarking banner from advanced structures india

Multimedia Data

We capture photos and wherever required, videos to show the functionality and feel of the specific feature.

Subsystem Level Features

Specific subsystem level features are mapped to ascertain its cost on the overall product.

Comparsion

Using xcPEP, you can view features side by side in photo and video form.

Product Planning

Feature mapping with cost allows you to plan your next product with precision and data.

Architecture Benchmarking

After disassembling the vehicle, it's crucial to preserve the layout, packaging, and subsystem interactions. This is achieved by mapping and creating detailed diagrams that effectively illustrate the architecture. This method has proven to be superior for retaining architectural information when compared to 3D scan data.

Tractor teardown and architecture view

Positioning

We map overall positioning of all crucial parts and subsystems with respect to relevant points and axes during benchmarking.

Packaging

While benchmarking vehicles or subsystems, we map how key components are packaged together.

Functionality

We also benchmark overall functionality of the part or subsystem while mapping its architecture.

Interface

During benchmarking, we map how all subsystems are connected with each other and type of interface. Interfaces can be mechanical, electrical, fluid etc.

Layout

We benchmark and draw detailed diagrams showing the layout of everything on the vehicle at different levels of teardown and in different views.

Part BOM Data Capture

In the detailed teardown process, we meticulously record over 50 parameters for each part, capturing all the necessary information to perform comprehensive should costing. The specific information captured per part may vary depending on the type of commodity.

vehicle teardown part data capturing by advanced structures india

Physical Dimensions

Depending on the type of part and its manufacturing process, we benchmark all parameters required for its should costing.

Supplier Identification

In most of the high value components, we map the suppliers for various cost analytics.

Precise Weight Measurement

We use a variety of weighing machines with required accuracy to map the weight of each part precisely. We maintain very high levels of accuracy in this activity.

Manufacturing Process

For different commodities, we map the manufacturing steps, required machines, labour and tools for conducting detailed should costing.

Raw Material Identification

We use a variety of tests to identify the composition and grade of the raw materials.

Photos and Videos

Besides detailed parameters, we also take all photographs from all views during benchmarking.

Should Costing

Following the measurement of all cost drivers for each part, we perform a thorough should costing analysis using xcPEP.

Should costing descriptive image for benchmarking page

Detailed Costing

And not weight based rough estimates.

Scenario Costing

On top of the first should costing done by us, you can create various scenarios in xcPEP and see the effect on part/subsystem/vehicle cost.

Business Case

Detailed should costing of competitor helps in making crystal clear business case before even concept level work is done.

Precise Targets

Using detailed should cost of competitor, engineering and purchase teams can be given precise weight and cost targets before the start of development program.

FAQs

About our teardown benchmarking services.
Who owns the benchmark data?
Our customers who have commissioned the study own the benchmark data.
What kind of vehicles / machines do you normally teardown?
We regularly work on all automotive and off highway vehicles / machines and their subsystems. We also work on home appliances, white goods and other engineered products from time to time.
What happens to data after the project?
It gets added to your organization's xcPEP server and your private benchmark database is built.
Is the data locked in xcPEP?
No, you can export data in excel and image formats as and when required. xcPEP is far more convenient for data consumption and collaboration and hence most of our customers remain on xcPEP.
What happens to torn down parts after teardown?
We do a workshop at your premises and arrange the parts for display. Post the workshop, we leave however parts are retained back by you for future use and scrapping as required.
Can you do teardown at our premises?
In most cases, its much cheaper, faster and convenient to do the activity at ASI premises in Bangalore. Your team gets full exposure to the parts during the workshop. Your team members may visit our premises as and when required in the middle of the project.
Do you provide xcPEP for our internal benchmarking team?
Yes, we provide xcPEP software licenses using which your in-house team can conduct the activities. We also provide training and deployment support for onboarding.